Introduction
Electric vehicles (EVs) are everywhere. Governments are pushing them, companies are advertising them as "clean and green," and buyers feel like they’re making a planet-friendly choice. But are EVs really better for the environment when you look at the full picture?
Hi, I’m Shubhangam Pandey, and at ResearchSpice, we dig deep into the data to help you make clear, informed decisions. Today, we’re going beyond the marketing to find the truth about EVs vs petrol/diesel cars.
How We Analyzed This
We used a method called Life-Cycle Assessment (LCA). It measures environmental impact at every stage:
-Raw material extraction-Manufacturing
-Operation (driving)
This helps us avoid the mistake of only focusing on tailpipe emissions.
What the Global Data Says
Globally, studies show EVs have lower lifetime CO₂ emissions than petrol/diesel cars, but by how much depends on where you live:
-Europe: EVs emit 66–69% less than petrol cars over their lifetime (source: ICCT, 2023).-United States: Around 60–68% less (source: IEA, 2023).
-China: Around 37–45% less, since the grid still uses a lot of coal (ScienceDirect, 2023).
-India: Only 19–34% less, and in some cases EVs can emit more CO₂ than petrol cars because our electricity grid is coal-heavy (ScienceDirect, 2022).
Key takeaway: EVs are clearly better in countries with clean electricity grids. In coal-heavy regions, the difference is smaller.
Battery Manufacturing: The Hidden Cost
EV batteries are huge contributors to emissions during production. Extracting lithium, cobalt, and nickel is energy intensive and harmful to ecosystems. For instance:
-Extracting 1 ton of lithium requires about 1.9 million liters of water (Wikipedia – Lithium-ion battery).This is why EVs start their life with a bigger carbon footprint than petrol cars. They only become cleaner over time as you drive and avoid burning fuel.
Non-Exhaust Emissions (What Nobody Talks About)
Here’s a surprising fact: EVs are heavier because of their batteries, and this means they create more tire and road dust. Some studies suggest this dust pollution could be 1,800 times higher than filtered tailpipe emissions from petrol cars (NY Post, 2024).
But on the plus side: EVs have no tailpipe, so they don’t emit harmful gases like NOx in cities, which improves air quality (Wikipedia – Environmental effects).
Battery Recycling – The Big Problem
Right now, less than 5% of EV batteries are recycled (Nature, 2023). This means most end up in landfills or are stored, waiting for better recycling technology.
The good news is, newer methods (like direct recycling and remanufacturing) are on the way and could make EVs far more sustainable in the next 5–10 years (ScienceDirect, 2023).
India’s Reality Check
Because India’s electricity grid is 70% coal-based, EVs here don’t perform as cleanly as in Europe or the US. A 2022 study found that EVs in India can actually emit up to 40% more CO₂ than petrol cars if the electricity used for charging is coal-heavy (ScienceDirect, 2022).
This means India needs a cleaner energy grid to unlock EVs’ real environmental benefits.
What Should You Do? (The Conclusion)
-If you live in a country or state with renewable-heavy electricity (solar, wind, hydro), buying an EV now is a great move for the planet.
-If your region’s electricity is coal-dominated (like India), EVs are not a magic solution. They’re still better for city air quality, but from a climate perspective, the benefits are smaller.-Push for better battery recycling and cleaner manufacturing. Without it, EVs can only go so far.
And finally, consider using your car longer and driving less—this matters more than the type of car.
Final Thoughts
At ResearchSpice, our goal is to cut through the hype and give you facts. EVs are not perfect, but they’re a big step forward if we also clean up our electricity grids and fix battery recycling.
This article was researched and written by Shubhangam Pandey (ResearchSpice), using verified sources from ICCT, IEA, ScienceDirect, Wikipedia, and Nature.
0 Comments